Understanding Capacity to Make a Will: Legal Insights
- Rikesh Wadhwa
- Apr 4
- 4 min read
When it comes to drafting a Will, one of the fundamental legal requirements is that the person making the will — known as the testator — must have the necessary mental capacity. Without capacity, a Will can be contested and potentially deemed invalid. This concept of "capacity" can seem vague to many, but it’s a critical issue in estate planning.
What Does It Mean to Have Capacity to Make a Will?
Having “capacity" refers to a person’s mental ability to understand the nature and consequences of their decisions. Specifically, when it comes to making a will, a person must meet the following criteria:
Understanding the Nature of the Act – The testator must be aware that they are creating a Will.
Understanding the Extent of Their Estate – The testator should have a clear understanding of the nature and extent of their property and assets. An exact inventory of everything they own isn’t necessary, but they should know the general scope of their estate.
Knowing the People Who Are Important – The testator must know who their close family members and loved ones are, as well as how their Will may impact these individuals or groups. This includes understanding who might reasonably expect to inherit from them.
Ability to Make Dispositions of Property – The testator should be capable of making rational decisions about how to distribute their estate. They must not be unduly influenced by others or acting under duress.
What Happens If a Person Lacks Capacity?
If someone lacks the mental capacity to make a Will, any Will they create while they lack capacity can be challenged in Court. A person lacking capacity may not fully understand the impact of their decisions, making it difficult for them to create a Will that reflects their true wishes. In such cases, the Court may find the Will invalid, and the estate may be distributed according to the laws of intestacy, meaning the rules for distributing an estate when there is no valid Will.
How Do Courts Assess Capacity?
Courts look at the circumstances surrounding the creation of the will and evaluate the testator’s mental state at the time the will was made. Common factors considered include:
Medical Evidence – If there’s evidence that the testator was suffering from a condition that affects mental capacity, such as dementia, the court may require medical records or expert testimony to assess their ability to understand the consequences of making a will.
Witness Testimony – The witnesses who were present when the will was made can provide testimony about the testator’s state of mind at that time. If the testator seemed confused or unable to understand their actions, it could be a sign that they lacked capacity.
Consistency in Decision-Making – If the testator’s decisions are inconsistent or irrational — for example, if they suddenly change their will and leave large sums of money to strangers or entities they have no connection with — this could be a red flag for a lack of capacity.
Preventing Challenges to Your Will
If you’re concerned about your capacity to make a will or want to ensure your will is legally sound, there are several steps you can take:
Consult with an Attorney – A qualified estate planning attorney can help ensure that your will is drafted properly and in accordance with the law. They can also document your capacity at the time of creating the will, which can help defend it in the event of a challenge.
Include a "Self-Proving" Affidavit – A self-proving affidavit is a sworn statement that can be included with the will to affirm that the testator had the requisite mental capacity when making the will. This can make it easier for the will to be admitted to probate without further evidence.
Get Medical Documentation – If you have concerns about your mental capacity, or if you’re drafting a will later in life or after a significant health change, getting a medical evaluation that confirms your mental competence can provide extra peace of mind.
Regularly Review Your Will – Reviewing and updating your will regularly ensures that it reflects your current intentions and gives you the opportunity to confirm that you still have the mental capacity to make changes.
What If a Will Is Challenged?
If someone contests your Will after your death, they may claim that you lacked the capacity to make it. If this happens, the burden of proof lies with the person challenging the will. They must provide evidence that you did not meet the necessary criteria for capacity when you created the will.
In some cases, the challenge can be resolved in Court through the presentation of medical records, witness testimony, and expert opinions. If a Court determines that you lacked capacity, the Will you created may be deemed invalid, and the estate will be distributed according to the laws of intestacy.
Conclusion
Having the mental capacity to make a Will is a crucial element in the estate planning process. It ensures that your wishes will be respected after your death and that your estate Will be distributed according to your intentions. By understanding the legal requirements for capacity and taking steps to ensure your will is properly executed, you can avoid future legal challenges and secure peace of mind for yourself and your loved ones. Always consult with a qualified attorney to ensure your Will is valid and reflective of your true desires.
Comments