Surrogacy for Same-Sex Parents in Alberta: Navigating Legal Challenges and Opportunities

Surrogacy offers an exciting opportunity for same-sex couples in Alberta to build their families. However, the process involves navigating a complex legal landscape governed by both federal and provincial laws. Understanding these regulations and the steps involved is crucial to ensuring that both the intended parents and the surrogate are protected throughout the journey.

Altruistic Surrogacy in Canada

Surrogacy in Canada operates under strict regulations that differ significantly from countries like the United States. The Assisted Human Reproduction Act (AHRA) prohibits commercial surrogacy, allowing only altruistic surrogacy. This means that intended parents cannot financially compensate the surrogate for carrying the child, although they can reimburse her for pregnancy-related expenses. The surrogate must also meet specific legal criteria, including being at least 21 years old.

For same-sex couples, the altruistic model ensures that surrogacy arrangements remain ethical and non-commercial, but it requires careful legal planning to ensure compliance with the AHRA. Establishing clear boundaries and expectations from the outset is essential.

Legal Parentage and the Family Law Act

In Alberta, the Family Law Act outlines the legal process for transferring parental rights from the surrogate to the intended parents. This process typically involves a court application, where the surrogate is legally declared not the parent, and the intended parents—those who provided the reproductive material—are recognized as the child’s legal parents. This step is crucial for ensuring that the intended parents have full parental rights from birth.

However, the Family Law Act still uses gendered language, referring only to "male" and "female" persons providing reproductive material, which can complicate the process for non-binary or non-gendered individuals. For queer families, this might result in an additional step where the non-biological parent must go through a step-parent adoption process to be fully recognized as a legal parent.

Surrogacy Agreements: A Critical Step

A well-drafted Surrogacy Agreement is a vital part of the surrogacy journey. This legal document outlines the rights and responsibilities of the intended parents and the surrogate, covering everything from medical procedures to reimbursements and expectations during the pregnancy. The agreement helps to prevent future disputes by clearly defining the surrogate’s role and establishing her consent to relinquish parental rights after the birth.

In Alberta, where surrogacy regulations are still relatively limited, having a detailed and enforceable agreement is especially important. It ensures that all parties are fully aware of their rights and obligations, reducing the risk of legal complications down the road.

Step-Parent Adoption for LGBTQIA2S+ Families

One of the unique challenges faced by same-sex couples is the need for step-parent adoption in cases where one partner is not genetically related to the child. After the court declares the biological parent, the non-biological parent must adopt the child to secure legal parentage. While this may seem like an additional burden, it is a necessary step to ensure that both partners are fully recognized as parents in the eyes of the law.

This second legal process reinforces the importance of thorough legal preparation. For LGBTQIA2S+ couples, working with an experienced lawyer who understands surrogacy and family law is critical to ensuring that the process goes smoothly and that both partners can enjoy equal parental rights.

---

Conclusion

Surrogacy presents an exciting opportunity for same-sex couples in Alberta to build their families. However, the legal landscape requires careful navigation, from ensuring compliance with the Assisted Human Reproduction Act to securing parental rights under the Family Law Act. By drafting comprehensive surrogacy agreements, going through step-parent adoption if needed, and seeking professional legal support, LGBTQIA2S+ couples can successfully navigate the surrogacy process while safeguarding their parental rights.

At Stokes Law, we understand the complexities of surrogacy law for same-sex parents. Our team is here to guide you through every legal step, from drafting Surrogacy Agreements to completing parental declarations and adoption processes. With our expertise, you can confidently embrace your journey to parenthood while ensuring all legal aspects are taken care of. Reach out to us today to learn more about how we can support you in building your family.

BOOK A CONSULT